Two weeks ago, a special election was held in Missouri House district 97, which covers parts of Arnold and Fenton, including a small slice of St. Louis County. The election was necessary because Rep. John McCaherty (GOP), who was in his 4th and final term in that seat (due to term limits), resigned to focus on his run for county executive, which he has since decided to back out of.
In the special election, Democrat Mike Revis defeated Republican David Linton in an upset. Revis brought in 51.5% of the vote and won with a 108-vote margin.
Of course, this got Democrats excited, even on the national level, sure that this means a blue wave is coming in November. Some examples:
Trump won this district 61-33. It just flipped from R to D. Congrats to @s_webber and the @MoDemParty. https://t.co/p2ZmKLYTkY
— Jason Kander (@JasonKander) February 7, 2018
🔵BLUE WAVE🔵
Democrat Mike Revis won the special election for a DEEPLY RED Missouri state rep seat by 3%. Trump won his district by 28 points, representing a THIRTY-ONE POINT SWING‼️👏🏼👏🏼#BlueWave2018https://t.co/f28BbsoSR9
— Dr. Dena Grayson (@DrDenaGrayson) February 7, 2018
I think the Trump comparison is not that relevant. Trump was running against Hillary Clinton. If Clinton had run as the candidate in district 97, she would have lost big there once again. Instead, the local Democratic party nominated a moderate candidate who touts his NRA membership. And using the presidential election results to suggest that the 97th district is “deeply red” is erroneous. Keep in mind that McCaherty was a firm no on right-to-work legislation, reflecting the views of the district.
And Trump was not running either. Instead, the county GOP committee, a sclerotic, pro-establishment bunch that is primarily interested in getting themselves re-elected to the committee and that probably thought Jeb Bush would win the 2016 GOP nomination, chose a candidate who was blamed by at least one person for losing the seat:
Rep. Kevin Engler, R-Farmington, blamed the Jefferson County loss on a weak candidate.
“I’ve won a lot of Democratic races for Republicans,” Engler said. “In order to do that, you have to outwork your opponent, not kind of work your opponent.”
Some blamed Governor Greitens and his current scandal for the loss:
Have you seen @EricGreitens’ numbers in District 97 both before and after his scandal(s) hit the news? I have. Killed the GOP there.
— Scott Dieckhaus (@sdieckhaus) February 7, 2018
It should also be noted that 14,000 people voted in this race in 2016, when McCaherty had no Democrat opponent, versus the 3,500 that voted in the special election. While the labor union troops that were reportedly out in full force in this campaign can make a big difference in a low-turnout race, I think their efforts will be insufficient come November 2018.